ofthisandthat

Puzzle
Copyright © 2010 ofthisandthat.org.  
All rights reserved.
Questions and Comments
backfire@ofthisandthat.org
PUZZLE -- WHICH CURTAIN?

In the TV show "Let's Make a Deal", the host would offer the contestant a choice of
three curtains, one of which hid the grand prize.  After the player made his selection,
the host would part one of the two remaining curtains to reveal a booby prize like a
goat.  He would then offer the player the chance to switch to the remaining curtain if
he wished.

Question:  Should he switch, or should he keep his original choice?

SCROLL DOWN FOR SOLUTION:



















SOLUTION:  At the time he makes his first choice, the probability of the prize being
behind any one of the curtains is 1/3.  Thus the probability of the prize behind his
chosen curtain is 1/3 and behind the other two curtains together is 2/3.  When the
booby prize curtain is removed from the equation, the probability of the prize being
behind the two curtains not chosen remains 2/3, and now resides with the single
not-chosen curtain.  Therefore, he should switch.  He would double his chances of
winning.

Note:  One can think of two boxes:  one containing the chosen curtain (1/3
probability), the other containing the two not-chosen curtains with 2/3 probability of
the prize.  Just because part of the contents of the latter box are revealed, does not
change the 2/3 probability.