Questions and Comments


Copyright © 2017  
All rights reserved.
July 22, 2018


Uri Avnery

Source:  Gush Shalom

ONE CAN look at events in Gaza through the left or through the right eye. One can
condemn them as inhuman, cruel and mistaken, or justify them as necessary and

But there is one adjective that is beyond question: They are stupid.

If the late Barbara Tuchman were still alive, she might be tempted to add another
chapter to her groundbreaking opus "The March of Folly": a chapter titled "Eyeless in

THE LATEST episode in this epic started a few months ago, when independent
activists in the Gaza Strip called for a march to the Israeli border, which Hamas
supported. It was called "The Great March of Return", a symbolic gesture for the more
than a million Arab residents who fled or were evicted from their homes in the land
that became the State of Israel.

The Israeli authorities pretended to take this seriously. A frightening picture was
painted for the Israeli public: 1.8 million Arabs, men, women and children, would throw
themselves on the border fence, break through in many places, and storm Israel's
cities and villages. Terrifying.

Israeli sharpshooters were posted along the border and ordered to shoot anyone who
looked like a "ringleader". On several succeeding Fridays (the weekly Muslim holy
day) more than 150 unarmed protesters, including many children, were shot dead,
and many hundreds more severely wounded by gunfire, apart from those hurt by tear

The Israeli argument was that the victims were shot while trying to "storm the fences".
Actually, not a single such attempt was photographed, though hundreds of
photographers were posted on both sides of the fence.

Facing a world-wide protest, the army changed its orders and now only rarely kills
unarmed protesters. The Palestinians also changed their tactics: the main effort now
is to fly children's kites with burning tails and set Israeli fields near the Strip on fire.

Since the wind almost always blows from the West to the East, that is an easy way to
hurt Israel. Children can do it, and do. Now the Minister of Education demands that
the air force bomb the children. The Chief of Staff refuses, arguing that this is
"against the values of the Israeli army".

At present, half of our newspapers and TV newscasts are concerned with Gaza.
Everybody seems to agree that sooner or later a full-fledged war will break out there.

THE MAIN feature of this exercise is its utter stupidity.

Every military action must have a political aim. As the German military thinker, Carl
von Clausewitz, famously said: "War is but a continuation of politics by other means."

The Strip is 41 km long and 6 to 12 km wide. It is one of the most overcrowded places
on earth. Nominally it belongs to the largely theoretical State of Palestine, like the
West Bank, which is Israeli occupied. The Strip is in fact governed by the radical
Muslim Hamas party.

In the past, masses of Palestinian workers from Gaza streamed into Israel every day.
But since Hamas assumed power in the Strip, the Israeli government has imposed an
almost total blockade on land and sea. The Egyptian dictatorship, a close ally of Israel
and a deadly enemy of radical Islam, cooperates with Israel.

So what does Israel want? The preferred solution is to sink the entire strip and its
population into the sea. Failing that, what can be done?

The last thing Israel wants is to annex the Strip with its huge population, which cannot
be driven out. Also, Israel does not want to put up settlements in the Strip (the few
which were set up were withdrawn by Ariel Sharon, who thought that it was not
worthwhile to keep and defend them).

The real policy is to make life in Gaza so miserable, that the Gazans themselves will
rise and throw the Hamas authorities out. With this in mind, the water supply is
reduced to two hours a day, electricity the same. Employment hovers around 50%,
wages beneath the minimum. It is a picture of total misery.

Since everything that reaches Gaza must come through Israel (or Egypt), supplies are
often cut off completely for days as "punishment".

Alas, history shows that such methods seldom succeed. They only deepen the enmity.
So what can be done?

THE ANSWER is incredibly simple: sit down, talk and come to an agreement.

Yes, but how can you sit down with a mortal enemy, whose official ideology totally
rejects a Jewish State?

Islam, which (like every religion) has an answer to everything, recognizes something
called a "Hudna", which is a lasting armistice. This can go on for many decades and is
(religiously) kept.

For several years now, Hamas has been almost openly hinting that it is ready for a
long Hudna. Egypt has volunteered to mediate. Our government has totally ignored
the offer. A Hudna with the enemy? Out of the question! God forbid! Would be terribly
unpopular politically!

But it would be the sensible thing to do. Stop all hostile acts from both sides, say for
50 years. Abolish the blockade. Build a real harbor in Gaza city. Allow free trade
under some kind of military inspection. Same for an airport. Allow workers to find
employment in Israel, instead of importing workers from China and Romania. Turn
Gaza into a second Singapore. Allow free travel between Gaza and the West Bank by
a bridge or an exterritorial highway. Help to restore unity between the Gaza Strip and
the West Bank.

WHY NOT? The very idea is rejected by an ordinary Israeli on sight.

A deal with Hamas? Impossible!!! Hamas wants to destroy Israel. Everybody knows

I hear this many times, and always wonder about the stupidity of people who repeat

How does a group of a few hundred thousand "destroy" one of the worlds most
heavily armed states, a state that possesses nuclear bombs and submarines to
deliver them? How? With kites?

Both Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin pay us homage, the world's fascist dictators
and liberal presidents come to visit. How can Hamas pose a mortal danger?

Why doesn't Hamas stop hostilities by itself? Hamas has competitors, which are even
more radical. It does not dare to show any sign of weakness.

SOME DECADES ago the Arab world, on the initiative of Saudi Arabia, offered Israel
peace under several conditions, all of them acceptable. Successive Israel
governments have not only not accepted it, they have ignored it altogether.

There was some logic in this. The Israeli government wants to annex the West Bank. It
wants to get the Arab population out, and replace them with Jewish settlers. It
conducts this policy slowly, cautiously, but consistently.

It is a cruel policy, a detestable policy, yet it has some logic in it. If you really want to
achieve this abominable aim, the methods may be adequate. But this does not apply
to the Gaza Strip, which no one wants to annex. There, the methods are sheer folly.

THIS DOES not mean that the overall Israeli policy towards the Palestinians is any
more wise. It is not.

Binyamin Netanyahu and his hand-picked stupid ministers have no policy. Or so it
seems. In fact they do have an undeclared one: creeping annexation of the West

This is now going on at a quicker pace than before. The daily news gives the
impression that the entire government machine is now concentrating on this project.

This will lead directly to an apartheid-style state, where a large Jewish minority will
dominate an Arab majority.

For how long? One generation? Two? Three?

It has been said that a clever person is able to extricate himself from a trap into which
a wise person would not have fallen in the first place.

Stupid people do not extricate themselves. They are not even aware of the trap.