Questions and Comments


Copyright © 2010  
All rights reserved.
August 15, 2015 Independence Day

Sixty-eight years after independence -- are Hindu nationalists a danger to
other Indians?

By Divya Arya

Source: BBC Delhi --

A little more than a year since Narendra Modi's right-wing Hindu nationalist BJP swept
to power in India, there are fears that religiously motivated violence may be on the
rise. Some say the BJP has bred a culture of intolerance towards minorities that has
left even Hindus nervous of speaking out.

Just before Christmas the church of St Sebastian in Delhi was gutted by fire - one of
five churches in the capital to have been attacked in the past year.

The pastor of St Sebastian's, Father Anthony Francis, didn't believe the police theory
that the fire was caused by a short circuit so started gathering evidence himself. Only
when he showed officers a film of oil on top of puddles of water in the wrecked church,
did they start an arson investigation.

But no-one has been arrested in this case, or in relation to the four other church

The congregation of St Sebastian, meanwhile, gathers under plastic sheets
suspended from a nearby community centre.

India's much larger Muslim minority has also been under pressure.

In the months leading up to last year's election, violence flared between Muslims and
Hindus in the town of Muzzafarnagar, 100km (62 miles) north of Delhi, leaving more
than 60 people dead.

While no riots on that scale have occurred since, smaller incidents are common.

"Just like those riots, now Hindus in the villages are trying to drive Muslims out of the
villages - repeated attacks have created an atmosphere of fear," says Mohammad
Jamshed, whose brother-in-law, Deen Mohammad, was left paralysed in the sleepy
town of Kairana, not far from Muzzafarnagar, in May.

In a bitterly ironic twist, it happened as protesters held a demonstration to demand
police action to stop violence against Muslims.

"I stopped to watch and was hit by a bullet fired from inside a police car," says
18-year-old Deen Mohammad. "I felt numb, walked a few steps and then fell down.
Then I started vomiting blood."

He fears he will never walk again.

Police say the bullet recovered from Mohammad's body is not a type they use, but
they are investigating complaints that officers used excessive force that day.

The previous month a Muslim labourer in the nearby village of Shamli was returning
home from Delhi by train when a gang of about 10 Hindu men beat him brutally with
rods in the groin, before stealing his money and pulling his beard from his face by the

"The police have not done anything except register a complaint. And now when I go
out, I fear that something like this may happen again," says the man, giving his name
as Faizan, aged 26.

Stories such as these usually go unnoticed by the media. They seem to some all the
more worrying when seen alongside derogatory comments about minorities from a
number of BJP politicians.

  You cannot judge the government with isolated incidents of violence or isolated
statementsMukhtar Abbas Naqvi, Minister for Minorities

"Each Hindu woman should mother four children in order to protect the predominance
of Hindus," said one MP, Sakshi Maharaj.

"Should the country be led by sons of Ram [a Hindu god] or by sons of bastards?"
asked the country's Minister for Food Processing Niranjan Jyoti - implying that
non-Hindus were bastards.

Another MP, Giriraj Singh said, "Those opposing Modi will have to go to Pakistan."
Later he was appointed to be minister for micro, small and medium enterprises.

But according to the Minister for Minorities Mukhtar Abbas Naqvi, "You cannot judge
the government with isolated incidents of violence or isolated statements by some
Religious make-up of India
Religion         Percentage of population         
Hindu         80.5         Buddhist         0.8         
Muslim         13.4         Jain         0.4         
Christian         2.3         Other         0.6         
Sikh         1.9         Not stated         0.1         
Source: Census of India 2001         
Narendra Modi himself has presented a moderate face of Hindu nationalism since
becoming prime minister.

"Our government will not allow any religious group belonging to the majority or the
minority to incite hatred against others overtly or covertly," he said in February, under
pressure to respond to the church attacks.

But recently-released statistics on inter-communal violence for the first half of 2015
indicate that there has been a 30% increase compared with the same period of 2014 -
a total of 330 attacks, 51 of them fatal, compared with 252 attacks, of which 33 were
fatal, in 2014.

The Muzzafarnagar riots mean that the statistics for 2013 were even worse, however.

And even the events of Muzzafarnagar pale in comparison with the anti-Muslim riots in
Gujarat in 2002 when Narendra Modi was the state's chief minister. Then, more than
1,000 people, mostly Muslims, were killed in clashes after 60 Hindu pilgrims died in a
fire on a train.

There are other forms of discrimination, as well as outright violence, which are harder
to measure.

"It's not just whether you go and kill Muslims and chase them out, it's not just about
burning someone's house down, it's denying them jobs, it's denying them places to
stay, it's making them live in terror," says Booker prize-winning author Arundhati Roy.

"While Modi pretends to be a statesman and travel to various places and is
pressurised to speak the language of diversity, the goons have been unleashed on
the ground."

Even middle-class urban Indians like herself, she says, are now wary of criticising the
ideology of Hindu nationalism.

"It's not just Muslims or Christians, perhaps the people they hate the most are the
ones who are standing up for a different way of looking at the world, and therefore
need to be silenced."
Father Anthony says the burning of his church "was like burning India's constitution",
with its guarantees of religious freedom