Questions and Comments


Copyright © 2010  
All rights reserved.
January 14, 2016

Obama’s final State of the Union:  half-truths evasions and threats

By Patrick Martin


The final State of the Union speech delivered Tuesday night by President Barack
Obama was a demonstration of the incapacity of the American political system to deal
honestly or seriously with a single social question.

Obama evaded the real issues that affect tens of millions of working people in
America every day of their lives. He painted a ludicrous picture of economic recovery
and social progress that insulted the intelligence of his television audience—and went
unchallenged by the millionaire politicians assembled in the chamber of the House of

Summing up what he called “the progress of these past seven years,” Obama gave
first place to “how we recovered from the worst economic crisis in generations.” The
so-called “recovery” has been a bonanza for corporate profits, stock prices, and the
wealth and income of the super-rich. For the working people who are the vast majority
of the population, it has been a disaster.

By most social indices, the American people are worse off in January 2016 than when
Obama took office seven years ago. The real wages of working people have fallen,
social services have deteriorated, pension benefits have been gutted, and cities such
as Detroit and San Bernardino have been forced into bankruptcy.

According to a report by the National Association of Counties issued on the eve of the
State of the Union address, of the 3,069 counties in the United States, 93 percent are
worse off than before the 2008 financial crash according to at least one of four
economic indicators: total employment, the unemployment rate, the size of the
economy and home values.

In 27 states, not a single county has recovered fully from the 2008 crash and the
deep economic slump that followed. These include such major states as Florida,
Georgia, Illinois, Massachusetts, Missouri, New Jersey, New York and Pennsylvania.

Obama, however, painted a picture of nearly unblemished economic advance,
declaring, “The United States of America, right now, has the strongest, most durable
economy in the world.” He boasted, “We’re in the middle of the longest streak of
private-sector job creation in history. More than 14 million new jobs; the strongest two
years of job growth since the ‘90s; an unemployment rate cut in half.”

The president did not acknowledge that the post-2008 “recovery” is the weakest on
record, that the vast majority of the new jobs created have been low-wage and many
of them part-time, or that the drop in the unemployment rate is primarily due to the
withdrawal of millions of people from the work force because they lost all hope of
getting a decent-paying job.

He went on, tellingly, to cite the auto industry as a symbol of success, declaring that it
“just had its best year ever.” This perfectly expresses the utter blindness, not just of
Obama, but of the entire political establishment. The “best year ever” was for General
Motors, Ford and Fiat-Chrysler, which enjoyed record profits, not for the auto workers
who produced those profits.

Real wages for auto workers have dropped sharply since the Obama White House
forced through a 50 percent cut in wages for all new hires as part of the bankruptcy
reorganization of the industry in 2009. Mass discontent among auto workers was
expressed at the end of 2015 in the rejection of contracts at Fiat-Chrysler and
Nexteer, a major supplier, and in widespread demands for strike action, smothered by
Obama’s stooges in the United Auto Workers union.

“Anyone claiming that America’s economy is in decline is peddling fiction,” Obama
concluded. The social position of the American working class has, in fact, suffered a
dramatic decline, through the combined efforts of the corporate bosses, the unions
and the two capitalist parties, the Democrats and Republicans.

The president conceded that economic inequality has grown in the United States, but
he described it as the outcome of long-term trends such as globalization and
automation, as though the policies of his administration—bailouts for Wall Street,
budget cuts and wage cuts for workers—had nothing to do with it.

In the seven years since the financial crash, brought on, as he admitted, by
“recklessness on Wall Street,” not a single banker or speculator has been prosecuted
or jailed. On the contrary, the billionaires have greatly increased their wealth,
gobbling up 95 percent of all new income since Obama entered the White House.

Obama listed a few other policy “successes,” claiming that “we reformed our health
care system, and reinvented our energy sector… we delivered more care and
benefits to our troops and veterans.” He was referring, however, to a series of social
disasters: the reactionary attack on health benefits for workers and their families
known as Obamacare; the devastation of Appalachia and other energy-producing
regions; and the abuse of ex-soldiers, wounded in body and mind, by the Veterans

Obama sought to defend the foreign policy record of his administration from criticism,
mainly from the Republican right, where demands are being raised for military
escalation in the Middle East and stepped-up attacks on democratic rights at home in
the name of fighting “terrorism.”

While he claimed to reject an American role as the world’s policeman, he nonetheless
boasted, “The United States of America is the most powerful nation on Earth. Period. It’
s not even close. We spend more on our military than the next eight nations

He continued, “Our troops are the finest fighting force in the history of the world,”
winning the bipartisan standing ovation that always accompanies any mention of
American soldiers engaged in combat overseas.

Obama indulged in the glorification of killing that has become an essential part of the
degraded spectacle that passes for political discourse in America. Describing the US
war against the Islamic State in Iraq and Syria, he claimed, “With nearly 10,000 air
strikes, we are taking out their leadership, their oil, their training camps, and their

He called on Congress to pass an Authorization for the Use of Military Force against
ISIS, but vowed to wage war with or without legislative approval. The leaders of ISIS,
he proclaimed, “will learn the same lessons as terrorists before them. If you doubt
America’s commitment—or mine—to see that justice is done, ask Osama bin Laden.
Ask the leader of al Qaeda in Yemen, who was taken out last year…”

Then he declared, in language that will be noted by nations all over the world, that
when it comes to waging war against potential adversaries, “our reach has no limit.”

Obama concluded his speech with an appeal to his Republican opponents to work
with his administration and pull back from the extreme anti-immigrant and anti-Muslim
rhetoric that has characterized the contest for the Republican presidential nomination.

In a clear reference to Donald Trump, he argued that “we need to reject any politics
that targets people because of race or religion. This is not a matter of political
correctness, but understanding what makes us strong.”

Obama was making an argument, not so much that racism and bigotry are intrinsically
wrong, but that they make it more difficult for American imperialism to maintain its
dominant world role. “When a politician insults Muslims,” he said, “it makes it harder to
achieve our goals.”