Questions and Comments


Copyright © 2010  
All rights reserved.
July 12, 2016


by Uri Avnery

Source:  Gush Shalom

A Palestinian youngster breaks into a settlement, enters the nearest house, stabs a
13-year old girl in her sleep and is killed.

Three Israeli men kidnap a 12-year old Palestinian boy at random, take him to an
open field and burn him alive.

Two Palestinians from a small town near Hebron enter Israel illegally, have coffee in a
Tel Aviv amusement quarter and then shoot up everybody around before they are
captured. They become national heroes.

An Israeli soldier sees a severely wounded Palestinian attacker lying on the ground,
approaches him and shoots him in the head at point blank range. He is applauded by
most Israelis.

These are not "normal" actions even in a guerrilla war. They are the manifestations of
bottomless hatred, a hatred so terrible that it overcomes all norms of humanity.

This was not always so. A few days after the 1967 war, in which Israel conquered East
Jerusalem, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, I traveled alone though the newly
occupied territories. I was welcomed almost everywhere, people were eager to sell me
their goods, tell me their stories. They were curious about the Israelis, much as we
were curious about them.

At the time, Palestinians did not dream of an eternal occupation. They hated the
Jordanian rulers and were glad that we had driven them out. They believed that we
would leave soon, allowing them to rule themselves at long last.

In Israel, everyone spoke about a "benevolent occupation". The first military governor
was a very humane person, Chaim Herzog, a future President of Israel and the father
of the present chairman of the Labor Party.

Within a few years, all this had changed. The Palestinians realized that the Israelis did
not intend to leave, but that they were about to steal their land, quite literally, and
cover it with their settlements.

(Something similar happened 15 years later in South Lebanon. The Shiite population
greeted our troops with flowers and rice, believing that we would drive the Palestinians
out and leave. When we didn’t, they turned into determined guerrilla fighters and
eventually founded Hezbollah.)

By now, hatred is everywhere. Arabs and Israelis use different highways, but it is far
worse than South African apartheid, because the whites there had no interest in
driving the blacks out. It is also far worse than most forms of colonialism, because the
imperial powers did not generally pull the land out from under the feet of the natives in
order to settle there.

Nowadays, mutual hatred reigns supreme. The settlers terrorize their Arab neighbors,
Arab boys throw rocks and improvised fire-bombs at passing Jewish cars on the
highroads where they themselves are not allowed to drive. Recently, the car of a high-
ranking army officer was stoned. He got out, pursued a boy who was running away,
shot him in the back and killed him – in flagrant violation of army rules for opening fire.

Today, some 120 years after the beginning of the Zionist experiment, the hatred
between the two peoples is abysmal. The conflict dominates our lives. More than half
of all news stories in the media concern this conflict.

If the founder of modern Zionism, the Viennese journalist Theodor Herzl, were to come
to life again, he would be totally shocked. In the futuristic novel he wrote in German at
the beginning of last century, called Altneuland ("Old-new Land"), he described in
detail life in the future Jewish State. Its Arab inhabitants are portrayed as happy and
patriotic citizens, grateful for all the progress and advantages brought by the Zionists.

In the beginning of the Jewish immigration, the Arabs were indeed remarkably
acquiescent. Perhaps they believed that the Zionists were a new version of the
German religious immigrants who had arrived a few decades earlier and indeed
brought progress to the country. These Germans, who called themselves Templars
(no connection with the medieval crusader group so called) had no political ambitions.
They set up model villages and urban neighborhoods and lived happily ever after,
until the German Nazis infected them. At the outbreak of World War II the British
deported them all to faraway Australia.

The model village these Templars built near Jaffa, Sarona, is now an amusement park
in Tel Aviv – the very place where the latest terrorist outrage took place.

When the Arabs realized that the new Zionist immigrants were not a repeat of the
Templars, but a new aggressive colonialist implantation, conflict became inevitable. It
grows worse from year to year. The hatred between the two peoples seems to reach
new heights all the time.

By now, the two peoples seem to live in two different worlds. A centuries-old Arab
village and a new Israeli settlement, situated one mile apart, might just as well exist on
two different planets.

From their first day on earth, children of the two peoples hear totally different stories
from their parents. This goes on in school. By the time they are grown up, they have
very few perceptions in common.

For a young Palestinian, the story is quite simple. This was an Arab land for more
than 14 centuries, a part of Arab civilization. For some, their ownership of the country
goes back thousands of years, since Islam did not displace the existing Christian
population when it conquered Palestine. Islam was at the time a much more
progressive religion, so local Christians gradually adopted Islam, too.

In the Palestinian view, Jews ruled Palestine in antiquity for a few decades only. The
Jewish claim to the country now, based on a promise given to them by their own
private Jewish God, is a blatant colonialist ploy. The Zionists came to the country in
the 20th century as allies of the British imperialist power, without any right to it.

Most Palestinians are now ready to make peace and even to live in a reduced
Palestinian state side by side with Israel, but are rebuffed by the Israeli government,
which wants to keep "all of Eretz Israel" for Jewish colonization, leaving only some
disconnected enclaves to the Palestinians.

A Palestinian Arab who believes that this is a self-evident truth may live a few hundred
yards away from a Jewish Israeli, who believes that this is all a pack of lies, invented
by Arab anti-Semites (an oxymoron) in order to drive the Jews into the sea. Every
Jewish child in Israel learns from an early age that this land was given by God to the
Jews, who ruled it for many centuries, until they offended God and He drove them out
as a temporary punishment. Now the Jews have come back to their country, which was
occupied by a foreign people which came from Arabia. These people now have the
cheek to claim the country as their own.

This being so, official Israeli doctrine says, there is no solution. We just have to be
ready for a very very long time – practically for eternity – to defend ourselves and our
country. Peace is a dangerous illusion.

The naïve vision of Herzl was opposed by the right-wing Zionist leader Vladimir (Ze’ev)
Jabotinsky. He stated – quite rightly – that nowhere in the world has a native people
ever give up its land peacefully to a foreigner. Therefore, he said, we have to build an
"iron wall" to defend our new settlement in the country of our forebears.

Jabotinsky, who had studied in the liberal post-Risorgimento Italy, had a liberal world-
view. His present-day followers are Binyamin Netanyahu and the Likud party, who are
anything but liberal.

They would applaud wildly if God made all Palestinians disappear overnight from "our"
country. They might even consider helping God a little bit.

Indeed, God plays an ever growing role in the conflict.

In the beginning, God played a very minor role. Almost all first-generation Zionists,
including both Herzl and Jabotinsky, were staunch atheists. It was said that Zionists
were people who did not believe in God, but who believed that God had promised us
the country.

This has radically changed – on both sides.

In the beginning of the conflict, early last century, the entire Arab world was infected
with European-style nationalism. Islam was always there, but it was not the driving
force. Arab national heroes, like Gamal Abd-al-Nasser, were avid nationalists, who
promised to unify the Arabs and turn them into a world power.

Arab nationalism failed miserably. Communism never took root in the Islamic
countries. Political Islam, which was victorious against the Soviets in Afghanistan, is
gaining ground throughout the Arab world.

Curiously enough, the same happened in Israel. After the 1967 war, in which Israel
completed its conquest of the Holy Land, and especially the Temple Mount and the
Western Wall, atheist Zionism steadily lost ground, and a violent religious kind of
Zionism took over.

In the Semitic world, the European idea of separation between state and church never
really took root. In both Islam and Judaism, religion and State are inseparable.

In Israel, power is now wielded by a government dominated by the extreme ideology of
the religious right-wing, while the "secular" left-wing has long been in full retreat.

In the Arab world, the same is happening – only more so. Al-Qaeda, Daesh and their
ilk are gaining everywhere. In Egypt and other places, military dictatorships try to stop
this process, but their foundations are shaky.

Some of us Israeli atheists have been warning of this danger for decades. We said
that nationalist states can reach compromise and make peace, while for religious
movements this is almost impossible.

Secular rulers can be assassinated, like Muammar Gaddafi in Libya and Yitzhak
Rabin in Israel. Religious movements live on when this happens to their leaders.

(Assassin is a corruption of the Arab Word Hashisheen. The 12th century founder of
this sect, the Old Man of the Mountain, used to feed his emissaries with Hashish and
send them on incredibly daring missions. The great Salah-ad-Din (Saladin) once woke
up in his bed to find a dagger next to him – and hastened to make a deal with the
leader of the Assassins.)

I am convinced that it is in the vital interest of Israel to make peace with the
Palestinian people, and with the Arab world at large, before this dangerous infection
engulfs the entire Arab – and Muslim – world.

The leaders of the Palestinian people, both in the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, are
still comparatively moderate people. This is true even for Hamas, a religious

I would suggest that for the West in general, supporting peace in our region is also of
paramount importance. The convulsions now affecting several Arab countries do not
bode well for them, either.

Reading a document like this week’s Quartet report on the Middle East, I am amazed
by their self-destructive cynicism. This ridiculous document of the Quartet, composed
of the US, Europe, Russia and the UN, is intent on creating an equilibrium – equally
blaming the conqueror and the conquered, the oppressor and the oppressed,
ignoring the occupation altogether. Verily, a masterpiece of hypocrisy, a.k.a.

Absent all chances for a serious effort for peace, hatred will just grow and grow, until it
engulfs us all.

Unless we take action to stem it in time.