 |
| |
 |
| |
 |
| |
 |
| |
 |
| |
 |
| |
 |
| |
 |
| |
 |
| |
 |
| |
 |
| |
 |
| |
 |
| Questions and Comments backfire@ofthisandthat.org |
ofthisandthat Commentary |
Copyright © 2017 ofthisandthat.org.
All rights reserved.
All rights reserved.
July 9, 2017
EYELESS IN GAZA
Uri Avnery
Source: Gush Shalom
I HAVE a unique confession to make: I like Gaza.
Yes, I like this far-away corner of Palestine, the narrow strip on the way to Egypt, in
which two million human beings are crowded, and which is closer to hell than to
heaven.
My heart goes out to them.
I HAVE spent quite a lot of time in the Strip. Once or twice I stayed there with Rachel
for a couple of days. I became friendly with some people whom I admired, people like
Dr. Haidar Abd-al-Shafi, the leftist doctor who set up the Gazan health system, and
Rashad al-Shawa, the former Mayor, an aristocrat from birth.
After the Oslo agreement, when Yasser Arafat came back to the country and set up
his office in Gaza, I met him there many times. I brought to him groups of Israelis. On
his first day there he sat me on the dais next to him. A photo of that occasion now
looks like science fiction.
I even came to know the Hamas people. Before Oslo, when Yitzhak Rabin deported
415 Islamic activists from the country, I took part in setting up protest tents opposite
his office. We lived there together, Jews, Christians and Muslims, and there Gush
Shalom was born. After a year, when the deportees were allowed back, I was invited
to a public reception for them in Gaza and found myself speaking to hundreds of
bearded faces. Among them were some of today's Hamas leaders.
Therefore I cannot treat the inhabitants of the Gaza Strip as a faceless gray mass of
people. I couldn't stop thinking about them during last week's terrible heat wave,
about the people languishing in awful conditions, without electricity and air
conditioning, without clean water, without medicines for the sick. I thought about those
living in the houses severely damaged in the last wars and not repaired since. About
the men and women, the old, the children, the toddlers, the babies.
My heart was bleeding, and was asking who was to blame.
Yes, who is to blame for this ongoing atrocity?
ACCORDING TO the Israelis, "the Palestinians themselves are to blame". Fact: the
Palestinian leadership in Ramallah has decided to reduce the electricity supply to
Gaza from three hours a day to two. (The electricity is supplied by Israel and paid for
by the Palestinian Authority in Ramallah.)
This seems to be true. The conflict between the Palestinian Authority, ruled by Fatah,
and the Palestinian leadership in Gaza, ruled by Hamas, has come to an ugly climax.
The uninvolved bystander wonders: how can that be? After all, the entire Palestinian
people are in existential danger. The Israeli government tyrannizes all Palestinians,
both in the West Bank and in the Gaza Strip. It keeps the Strip under a strangling
blockade, on land, in the sea and in the air, and is setting up settlements all over the
West Bank, to drive the population out.
In this desperate situation, how can the Palestinians fight each other, to the obvious
delight of the occupation authorities?
That is terrible, but, sadly, not unique. On the contrary, in almost all liberation
struggles, something similar has happened. During the Irish struggle for
independence, the freedom fighters fought against each other and even shot each
other. During our own struggle for statehood, the Haganah underground turned Irgun
fighters over to the British police, who tortured them, and later shot up a ship bringing
recruits and arms to the Irgun.
But these and many other examples do not justify what is happening now in Gaza.
The struggle between Fatah and Hamas on the backs of two million people condemns
these to inhuman living conditions.
As an old friend of the Palestinian people in their fight for liberation, I am deeply
saddened.
BUT THERE are more partners to the atrocious blockade on Gaza.
Israel can blockade the Strip only on three sides. The fourth side is the Egyptian
border. Egypt, which has in the past fought four major wars against Israel on behalf of
the Palestinian brothers (in one of which I was wounded by an Egyptian machine-
gunner) is now participating in the cruel blockade on the Strip.
What has happened? How did it happen?
Everyone who knows the Egyptian people knows that it is one of the most attractive
peoples on earth. A very proud people. A people full of humor even in the most trying
circumstances. Several times I have heard in Egypt phrases like: "We do not like the
Palestinians very much, but they are our poor cousins, and we cannot abandon them
under any circumstances!"
And here they are, not only abandoning, but cooperating with the cruel occupation.
All this why? Because the local rulers in Gaza are religious fanatics, just like the
Muslim Brothers in Egypt who are the deadly enemies of today's Pharaoh, General
Abd-al-Fatah al-Sisi. Because of this enmity, millions in Gaza are punished.
Now rumor has it that Egypt would relent, if the Gazans accept an Egyptian stooge as
their ruler.
The Israeli blockade of Gaza is completely dependent on the Egyptian blockade.
Proud Egypt, which claims to be the leader the entire Arab World, has become the
handmaiden of the Israeli occupation.
Who would have believed it?.
BUT THE main responsibility for the atrocity in Gaza falls, of course, on us, on Israel.
We are the occupiers – a novel type of occupation by blockade.
The justification is clear: They want to destroy us. That is the official doctrine of
Hamas. The mouse hurls terrible threats against the elephant.
True. But…
But like all religious people, they find a hundred different ways to cheat God and get
around His prohibitions.
Hamas has declared that if Mahmood Abbas made peace with Israel, and if the
Palestinian people confirmed the peace by plebiscite, Hamas would accept it.
Also, Islam allows for a Hudna (armistice) with infidels for any length of time – 10, 50,
100 years. After that, Allah is great.
In many hidden ways, Israel does cooperate with Hamas, especially against the even
more extreme Islamists in the Strip. We could easily reach a modus vivendi all along
the line.
SO WHY must the people in Gaza suffer so grievously? No one really knows. Because
of the mental laziness of the occupation. Because that's what we are used to doing.
Here is a mental exercise: What if we did the very opposite?
What if we announced to the people in the Gaza Strip: the Palestinian Authority in
Ramallah is now paying for only two hours of electricity a day. But seeing your
suffering, Israel has decided to provide you with electricity for 24 hours for free.
What would be the effect? How would Hamas react? How would it affect the level of
violence and security costs?
For the long run, there are many Israeli and international plans. An artificial island in
the Mediterranean opposite Gaza. An airport on the island. A deep-sea port. Peace in
fact, even without declarations.
I believe that this is the wisest way to proceed. But wisdom has little chance.
IN THE meantime, the atrocity goes on. Two million human beings suffer inhuman
treatment.
And the world? Alas. the world is busy. It has no eyes for Gaza. Better not to think
about that awful place.
EYELESS IN GAZA
Uri Avnery
Source: Gush Shalom
I HAVE a unique confession to make: I like Gaza.
Yes, I like this far-away corner of Palestine, the narrow strip on the way to Egypt, in
which two million human beings are crowded, and which is closer to hell than to
heaven.
My heart goes out to them.
I HAVE spent quite a lot of time in the Strip. Once or twice I stayed there with Rachel
for a couple of days. I became friendly with some people whom I admired, people like
Dr. Haidar Abd-al-Shafi, the leftist doctor who set up the Gazan health system, and
Rashad al-Shawa, the former Mayor, an aristocrat from birth.
After the Oslo agreement, when Yasser Arafat came back to the country and set up
his office in Gaza, I met him there many times. I brought to him groups of Israelis. On
his first day there he sat me on the dais next to him. A photo of that occasion now
looks like science fiction.
I even came to know the Hamas people. Before Oslo, when Yitzhak Rabin deported
415 Islamic activists from the country, I took part in setting up protest tents opposite
his office. We lived there together, Jews, Christians and Muslims, and there Gush
Shalom was born. After a year, when the deportees were allowed back, I was invited
to a public reception for them in Gaza and found myself speaking to hundreds of
bearded faces. Among them were some of today's Hamas leaders.
Therefore I cannot treat the inhabitants of the Gaza Strip as a faceless gray mass of
people. I couldn't stop thinking about them during last week's terrible heat wave,
about the people languishing in awful conditions, without electricity and air
conditioning, without clean water, without medicines for the sick. I thought about those
living in the houses severely damaged in the last wars and not repaired since. About
the men and women, the old, the children, the toddlers, the babies.
My heart was bleeding, and was asking who was to blame.
Yes, who is to blame for this ongoing atrocity?
ACCORDING TO the Israelis, "the Palestinians themselves are to blame". Fact: the
Palestinian leadership in Ramallah has decided to reduce the electricity supply to
Gaza from three hours a day to two. (The electricity is supplied by Israel and paid for
by the Palestinian Authority in Ramallah.)
This seems to be true. The conflict between the Palestinian Authority, ruled by Fatah,
and the Palestinian leadership in Gaza, ruled by Hamas, has come to an ugly climax.
The uninvolved bystander wonders: how can that be? After all, the entire Palestinian
people are in existential danger. The Israeli government tyrannizes all Palestinians,
both in the West Bank and in the Gaza Strip. It keeps the Strip under a strangling
blockade, on land, in the sea and in the air, and is setting up settlements all over the
West Bank, to drive the population out.
In this desperate situation, how can the Palestinians fight each other, to the obvious
delight of the occupation authorities?
That is terrible, but, sadly, not unique. On the contrary, in almost all liberation
struggles, something similar has happened. During the Irish struggle for
independence, the freedom fighters fought against each other and even shot each
other. During our own struggle for statehood, the Haganah underground turned Irgun
fighters over to the British police, who tortured them, and later shot up a ship bringing
recruits and arms to the Irgun.
But these and many other examples do not justify what is happening now in Gaza.
The struggle between Fatah and Hamas on the backs of two million people condemns
these to inhuman living conditions.
As an old friend of the Palestinian people in their fight for liberation, I am deeply
saddened.
BUT THERE are more partners to the atrocious blockade on Gaza.
Israel can blockade the Strip only on three sides. The fourth side is the Egyptian
border. Egypt, which has in the past fought four major wars against Israel on behalf of
the Palestinian brothers (in one of which I was wounded by an Egyptian machine-
gunner) is now participating in the cruel blockade on the Strip.
What has happened? How did it happen?
Everyone who knows the Egyptian people knows that it is one of the most attractive
peoples on earth. A very proud people. A people full of humor even in the most trying
circumstances. Several times I have heard in Egypt phrases like: "We do not like the
Palestinians very much, but they are our poor cousins, and we cannot abandon them
under any circumstances!"
And here they are, not only abandoning, but cooperating with the cruel occupation.
All this why? Because the local rulers in Gaza are religious fanatics, just like the
Muslim Brothers in Egypt who are the deadly enemies of today's Pharaoh, General
Abd-al-Fatah al-Sisi. Because of this enmity, millions in Gaza are punished.
Now rumor has it that Egypt would relent, if the Gazans accept an Egyptian stooge as
their ruler.
The Israeli blockade of Gaza is completely dependent on the Egyptian blockade.
Proud Egypt, which claims to be the leader the entire Arab World, has become the
handmaiden of the Israeli occupation.
Who would have believed it?.
BUT THE main responsibility for the atrocity in Gaza falls, of course, on us, on Israel.
We are the occupiers – a novel type of occupation by blockade.
The justification is clear: They want to destroy us. That is the official doctrine of
Hamas. The mouse hurls terrible threats against the elephant.
True. But…
But like all religious people, they find a hundred different ways to cheat God and get
around His prohibitions.
Hamas has declared that if Mahmood Abbas made peace with Israel, and if the
Palestinian people confirmed the peace by plebiscite, Hamas would accept it.
Also, Islam allows for a Hudna (armistice) with infidels for any length of time – 10, 50,
100 years. After that, Allah is great.
In many hidden ways, Israel does cooperate with Hamas, especially against the even
more extreme Islamists in the Strip. We could easily reach a modus vivendi all along
the line.
SO WHY must the people in Gaza suffer so grievously? No one really knows. Because
of the mental laziness of the occupation. Because that's what we are used to doing.
Here is a mental exercise: What if we did the very opposite?
What if we announced to the people in the Gaza Strip: the Palestinian Authority in
Ramallah is now paying for only two hours of electricity a day. But seeing your
suffering, Israel has decided to provide you with electricity for 24 hours for free.
What would be the effect? How would Hamas react? How would it affect the level of
violence and security costs?
For the long run, there are many Israeli and international plans. An artificial island in
the Mediterranean opposite Gaza. An airport on the island. A deep-sea port. Peace in
fact, even without declarations.
I believe that this is the wisest way to proceed. But wisdom has little chance.
IN THE meantime, the atrocity goes on. Two million human beings suffer inhuman
treatment.
And the world? Alas. the world is busy. It has no eyes for Gaza. Better not to think
about that awful place.