Questions and Comments


Copyright © 2010  
All rights reserved.
May 28, 2016


by Uri Avnery

Source: Gush Shalom

"Please don’t write about Ya’ir Golan!" a friend begged me, “Anything a leftist like you
writes will only harm him!"

So I abstained for some weeks. But I can’t keep quiet any longer.

General Ya’ir Golan, the deputy Chief of Staff of the Israeli army, made a speech on
Holocaust Memorial Day. Wearing his uniform, he read a prepared, well-considered
text that triggered an uproar which has not yet died down.

Dozens of articles have been published in its wake, some condemning him, some
lauding him. Seems that nobody could stay indifferent.

The main sentence was: "If there is something that frightens me about the memories
of the Holocaust, it is the knowledge of the awful processes which happened in
Europe in general, and in Germany in particular, 70, 80, 90 years ago, and finding
traces of them here in our midst, today, in 2016."

All hell broke loose. What!!! Traces of Nazism in Israel? A resemblance between what
the Nazis did to us with what we are doing to the Palestinians?

90 years ago was 1926, one of the last years of the German republic. 80 years ago
was 1936, three years after the Nazis came to power. 70 years ago was 1946, on the
morrow of Hitler’s suicide and the end of the Nazi Reich.

I feel compelled to write about the general’s speech after all, because I was there.

As a child I was an eyewitness to the last years of the Weimar Republic (so called
because its constitution was shaped in Weimar, the town of Goethe and Schiller). As a
politically alert boy I witnessed the Nazi Machtergreifung ("taking power") and the first
half a year of Nazi rule.

I know what Golan was speaking about. Though we belong to two different
generations, we share the same background. Both our families come from small towns
in Western Germany. His father and I must have had a lot in common.

There is a strict moral commandment in Israel: nothing can be compared to the
Holocaust. The Holocaust is unique. It happened to us, the Jews, because we are
unique. (Religious Jews would add: "Because God has chosen us".)

I have broken this commandment. Just before Golan was born, I published (in Hebrew)
a book called "The Swastika", in which I recounted my childhood memories and tried
to draw conclusions from them. It was on the eve of the Eichmann trial, and I was
shocked by the lack of knowledge about the Nazi era among young Israelis then.

My book did not deal with the Holocaust, which took place when I was already living in
Palestine, but with a question which troubled me throughout the years, and even
today: how could it happen that Germany, perhaps the most cultured nation on earth
at the time, the homeland of Goethe, Beethoven and Kant, could democratically elect
a raving psychopath like Adolf Hitler as its leader?

The last chapter of the book was entitled "It Can Happen Here!" The title was drawn
from a book by the American novelist Sinclair Lewis, called ironically "It Can’t Happen
Here", in which he described a Nazi takeover of the United States.

In this chapter I discussed the possibility of a Jewish Nazi-like party coming to power in
Israel. My conclusion was that a Nazi party can come to power in any country on
earth, if the conditions are right. Yes, in Israel, too.

The book was largely ignored by the Israeli public, which at the time was overwhelmed
by the storm of emotions evoked by the terrible disclosures of the Eichmann trial.

Now comes General Golan, an esteemed professional soldier, and says the same

And not as an improvised remark, but on an official occasion, wearing his general’s
uniform, reading from a prepared, well thought-out text.

The storm broke out, and has not passed yet.

Israelis have a self-protective habit: when confronted with inconvenient truths, they
evade its essence and deal with a secondary, unimportant aspect. Of all the dozens
and dozens of reactions in the written press, on TV and on political platforms, almost
none confronted the general’s painful contention.

No, the furious debate that broke out concerns the questions: Is a high-ranking army
officer allowed to voice an opinion about matters that concern the civilian
establishment? And do so in army uniform? On an official occasion?

Should an army officer keep quiet about his political convictions? Or voice them only
in closed sessions – "in relevant forums", as a furious Binyamin Netanyahu phrased it?

General Golan enjoys a very high degree of respect in the army. As Deputy Chief of
Staff he was until now almost certainly a candidate for Chief of Staff, when the
incumbent leaves the office after the customary four years.

The fulfillment of this dream shared by every General Staff officer is now very remote.
In practice, Golan has sacrificed his further advancement in order to utter his warning
and giving it the widest possible resonance.

One can only respect such courage. I have never met General Golan, I believe, and I
don’t know his political views. But I admire his act.

(Somehow I recall an article published by the British magazine Punch before World
War I, when a group of junior army officers issued a statement opposing the
government’s policy in Ireland. The magazine said that while disapproving the opinion
expressed by the mutinous officers, it took pride in the fact that such youthful officers
were ready to sacrifice their careers for their convictions.)

The Nazi march to power started in 1929, when a terrible worldwide economic crisis hit
Germany. A tiny, ridiculous far-right party suddenly became a political force to be
reckoned with. From there it took them four years to become the largest party in the
country and to take over power (though it still needed a coalition).

I was there when it happened, a boy in a family in which politics became the main topic
at the dinner table. I saw how the republic broke down, gradually, slowly, step by step.
I saw our family friends hoisting the swastika flag. I saw my high-school teacher raising
his arm when entering the class and saying "Heil Hitler" for the first time (and then
reassuring me in private that nothing had changed.)

I was the only Jew in the entire gymnasium (high school.) When the hundreds of boys
– all taller than I – raised their arms to sing the Nazi anthem, and I did not, they
threatened to break my bones if it happened again. A few days later we left Germany
for good.

General Golan was accused of comparing Israel to Nazi Germany. Nothing of the sort.
A careful reading of his text shows that he compared developments in Israel to the
events that led to the disintegration of the Weimar Republic. And that is a valid

Things happening in Israel, especially since the last election, bear a frightening
similarity to those events. True, the process is quite different. German fascism arose
from the humiliation of surrender in World War I, the occupation of the Ruhr by
France and Belgium from 1923-25, the terrible economic crisis of 1929, the misery of
millions of unemployed. Israel is victorious in its frequent military actions, we live
comfortable lives. The dangers threatening us are of a quite different nature. They
stem from our victories, not from our defeats.

Indeed, the differences between Israel today and Germany then are far greater than
the similarities. But those similarities do exist, and the general was right to point them

The discrimination against the Palestinians in practically all spheres of life can be
compared to the treatment of the Jews in the first phase of Nazi Germany. (The
oppression of the Palestinians in the occupied territories resembles more the
treatment of the Czechs in the "protectorate" after the Munich betrayal.)

The rain of racist bills in the Knesset, those already adopted and those in the works,
strongly resembles the laws adopted by the Reichstag in the early days of the Nazi
regime. Some rabbis call for a boycott of Arab shops. Like then. The call "Death to the
Arabs" ("Judah verrecke"?) is regularly heard at soccer matches. A member of
parliament has called for the separation between Jewish and Arab newborns in
hospital. A Chief Rabbi has declared that Goyim (non-Jews) were created by God to
serve the Jews. Our Ministers of Education and Culture are busy subduing the
schools, theater and arts to the extreme rightist line, something known in German as
Gleichschaltung. The Supreme Court, the pride of Israel, is being relentlessly
attacked by the Minister of Justice. The Gaza Strip is a huge ghetto.

Of course, no one in their right mind would even remotely compare Netanyahu to the
Fuehrer, but there are political parties here which do emit a strong fascist smell. The
political riffraff peopling the present Netanyahu government could easily have found
their place in the first Nazi government.

One of the main slogans of our present government is to replace the "old elite",
considered too liberal, with a new one. One of the main Nazi slogans was to replace
"das System".

By the way, when the Nazis came to power, almost all high-ranking officers of the
German army were staunch anti-Nazis. They were even considering a putsch against
Hitler . Their political leader was summarily executed a year later, when Hitler
liquidated his opponents in his own party. We are told that General Golan is now
protected by a personal bodyguard, something that has never happened to a general
in the annals of Israel.

The general did not mention the occupation and the settlements, which are under
army rule. But he did mention the episode which occurred shortly before he gave this
speech, and which is still shaking Israel now: in occupied Hebron, under army rule, a
soldier saw a seriously wounded Palestinian lying helplessly on the ground,
approached him and killed him with a shot to the head. The victim had tried to attack
some soldiers with a knife, but did not constitute a threat to anyone any more. This
was a clear contravention of army standing orders, and the soldier has been hauled
before a court martial.

A cry went up around the country: the soldier is a hero! He should be decorated!
Netanyahu called his father to assure him of his support. Avigdor Lieberman entered
the crowded courtroom in order to express his solidarity with the soldier. A few days
later Netanyahu appointed Lieberman as Minister of Defense, the second most
important office in Israel.

Before that, General Golan received robust support both from the Minister of
Defense, Moshe Ya’alon, and the Chief of Staff, Gadi Eisenkot. Probably this was the
immediate reason for the kicking out of Ya’alon and the appointment of Lieberman in
his place. It resembled a putsch.

It seems that Golan is not only a courageous officer, but a prophet, too. The inclusion
of Lieberman’s party in the government coalition confirms Golan’s blackest fears. This
is another fatal blow to the Israeli democracy.

Am I condemned to witness the same process for the second time in my life?

Uri Avnery is a peace activist, journalist, writer, and former member of the Israeli
Knesset. Read other articles by Uri, or visit Uri’s website.